Princess Mary Club – What are the alternatives?

Princess Mary Club - Lonsdale Street facade in c1985
Princess Mary Club – Lonsdale Street facade in c1985

On Tuesday our president Tristan Davies spoke at the City of Melbourne Committee meeting, objecting to the demolition of the Princess Mary Club (and other small buildings on the site) and the construction of a giant tower that will overwhelm the Wesley Church. Sadly all but three Councillors voted in favour, with the Lord Mayor saying ‘we cant save everything’. But, of course we don’t want to save everything, only the things that are worth saving! In this case we also argue that the proposed development does not meet Council’s own guidelines, i.e:

    • MSS Strategy 1.3 “Maintain the visual prominence of heritage buildings and landmarks.”
    • Urban Design within CCZ: “Towers should have a podium… to provide a context for heritage.”
    • Urban Design guideline: “Towers above the podium should be setback at least 10 metres from street frontages.” The new 5m rule is a minimum, not a standard.
Loss of Princess Mary Club Building over the manse Domination of church by tall close tower
Proposed Development: Loss of Princess Mary Club. Building over the manse. Domination of church by tall close tower.

We are not against redevelopment of sites with heritage buildings, but in this case we believe the scale of the development and the loss of heritage is inappropriate. At the meeting we presented some alternative options; both with less intrusive towers.

The first alternative retains one of the main facades of the Princess Mary Club to form part of a podium.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

The other accepts its loss, but moves the manse to the front of the site, instead of it being buried under the tower, to provide a better context for the church.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

If only options like these had been explored years ago. The role of Heritage Victoria, the City of Melbourne and the Planning Minister is not to simply say yes or no to development, but to explore and encourage the best planning outcomes.

 

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Princess Mary Club – What are the alternatives?

  1. We have just finished a documentary on why we are trying to save the Princess Mary Club. It goes for about 20 mins. I thought it may be of interest. Please feel free to share.

    Thanks Sophie

    Like

  2. My word on saving the Princess Mary Club. Yes I am very saddened that yet again more of our grand old buildings are disliked so much so that glass towers are to replace these. Yet to propose a truly heartfelt argument. Sadly the above film clip although the sentiment is in the right place it is lacking. More persuasive argument. As for the idea to allow the Mary Club to be the podium on which the office tower to sit on top. I don’t see this as happening also I think is safe nor architecturally going to be safe.

    Like

Join the discussion

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s